Law firm claims charges against police not based on “clear and fair grounds”

Tohi atu a e kautaha lao Taione Tu’utafaiva Law Firm ki he komisiona polisi ‘o fakahā ki ai ‘oku nau fakafofonga’i ha kau ‘ofisa polisi ‘e toko 17 kuo faka’ilo ki he faihia. ‘Oku tukuaki’i ‘e he kautaha lao ‘a e komisiona ki he ‘ikai fakatuhotuha tatau ‘ene founga he kuo tuli fakataimi ha toko nima kae ‘ikai tuli e toenga ia. Ko e tohi ni ne fakamo’oni ai ‘a Loea Sifa Tu’utafaiva pea ‘ave hono tatau ki he Minisitā Polisi. ‘Oku tukuaki’i ‘e he loea ‘oku ‘i ai e ni’ihi ia ‘i he kau polisi kuo tuli ne ma’ama’a pe hia ne nau fai taimi tatau ‘oku kei fakangaue’i pe ni’ihi ia ne mamafa ange ha’anautolu ia hia ne fakahoko. Na’e fokotu’u atu ‘e Tu’utafaiva ki he komisiona ke toe fakakaukau e keisi ‘a e ‘ofisa ko Malia Fanua ‘a ia ‘oku tuli ia ‘ikai ha’ane vahe.

A Tongan law firm has written to Police Commissioner Steven Caldwell claiming he has not acted fairly over charges and suspensions of 17 police officers.

The firm says only five of the officers have been suspended.

The letter, signed by Siosifa T. Tu’utafaiva, has been copied to the Minister of Police.

“We do not understand the reasons for suspending those five police officers and not the others,” Tu’utafaiva wrote.

“Some of the officers who are not suspended face serious allegations, and we are aware of the senior police officers who face serious criminal allegations but they are not suspended.”

Tu’utafaiva asked for the Commissioner to reconsider the case of Sergeant Malia Fanua, who he said had been suspended without pay.

Sgt Fanua had not been paid for three months.

He said officers who were facing criminal charges were still paid their salaries and not suspended from duty.

Tu’utafaiva, a former Minister of Police, said because no criminal proceedings had been commenced against Sgt Fanua, the decision to suspend her should be considered null and void.

“It may be not appropriate for you to comment on other cases currently under the disciplinary process, but those cases show that the exercise of your discretionary power to suspend police officers from duties is not based on clear and fair grounds,” he said.

Police Commissioner Caldwell has not responded to allegations about his handling of police discipline and corruption because he is restricted in what he can say publicly.

As Kaniva News reported earlier, Minister of Police, Hon. Mateni Tapueluelu, has openly sided with a number of officers protesting about their treatment.

Hon. Tapueluelu said the government told New Zealand Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern the government did not want the  Police Commissioner’s contract extended.

The Police Commissioner’s position is largely funded by New Zealand.

Last month a Police spokesman said officers had been suspended for “very good reasons.”

“The Commissioner is confined by what he can say publicly on individual criminal and disciplinary cases currently under investigation,” the spokesperson said.

Tonga’s police force has a troubled history of corruption and abuse.

It also has a history of New Zealand police officers working in Tonga being faced with entrenched opposition from police opposed to attempts to clean up the force.

For more information

Hon Lavulavu denies he told mechanical supervisor to fake TP$1 million valuation, threatens legal action

Petition complaints nothing new say police, as Commissioner works on cyclone recovery


Sometimes when a business is growing, it needs a little help.

Right now Kaniva News provides a free, politically independent, bilingual news service for readers around the world that is absolutely unique. We are the largest New Zealand-based Tongan news service, and our stories reach Tongans  wherever they are round the world. But as we grow, there are increased demands on Kaniva News for translation into Tongan on our social media accounts and for the costs associated with expansion. We believe it is important for Tongans to have their own voice and for Tongans to preserve their language, customs and heritage. That is something to which we are strongly committed. That’s why we are asking you to consider sponsoring our work and helping to preserve a uniquely Tongan point of view for our readers and listeners.

Latest news

Related news